SHENMUE III - REVIEW ROUNDUP

[Sput Vas Normandy]

Could it be a good idea to make a version where all scores are just one list? Instead of dividing them based on if they are on Metacritic or not. It's not like all sites on Metacritic are automatically more reliable/reputable than some of the unranked ones. FZ.se and Gamereactor are two examples that I think aren't worse than some of the ranked ones.

You right. You should do this Real1

 

[Real1]

5 more review on MC today
70 from Playstation country
60 from games.cz
60 from aus gamers
56 from New game Network
55 from ZTGD


Unfortunaly the Meta score drop to 69

I THOUGHT REVIEW WOULD HAVE SLOWED DOWN BY NOW. M`MGGILdnignfsidghidugsodifgmsdo

What a barrage of bad to awful scores from nowhere.

Updating list.

 

[Real1]

You right. You should do this Real1

On the to-do list. After reviews slow down. I made this thread thinking it had slowed down but then they go and dump 589873434934 new bad reviews today.

 

[Sput Vas Normandy]

On the to-do list. After reviews slow down. I made this thread thinking it had slowed down but then they go and dump 589873434934 new bad reviews today.

And I would mix the PS4 and PC list too, it's a bit silly to separate it, it's the same game anyway

All reviews:
6771 / 96 = 70.53

 

[Real1]

And I would mix the PS4 and PC list too, it's a big silly to separate it, it's the same game anyway

All reviews:
6771 / 96 = 70.53

Yeah, I'll do that!

We should round that to 71 just because we can.

Or weigh it. Digitally Downloaded's 100 review is worth 600x more than all other reviews.

 

[Sput Vas Normandy]

Yeah, I'll do that!

We should round that to 71 just because we can.

You know what, you're fucking right

6771 / 96 = 71

 

[Real1]

New review that won't go on metacritic from a site called FutureFive. They give it an 8, and it's reviewed by someone completely new to Shenmue! https://futurefive.co.nz/story/game-review-shenmue-iii-is-a-nice-surprise

EDIT: found on Twitter through ShenmueForever

 

[Real1]

For some reason, RockPaperShotgun's review was not on the list. It is now and I highly recommend people watch it actually. Surprised to see how well the reviewer understands the appeal of Shenmue.

 

[Sput Vas Normandy]

You know what, you're fucking right

6771 / 96 = 71

And the "steam way" (I consider this method the better and fairness):
80 positive (60 or +) of 96

83.3% positive

 

[Real1]

And the "steam way" (I consider this method the better and fairness):
80 positive (60 or +) of 96

83.3% positive

I think we should settle on this way haha

 

[Sput Vas Normandy]

I think we should settle on this way haha

You know what, just delete all the reviews and let's put only this in the first message

 

[Kyo_JP]

From Italian site GameSailors.it here it come another 80 https://www.gamesailors.it/recensione/shenmue-3/12854 written and in video (2k followers on Twitter, 10k aprox on YT)

EDIT:
Not scored but positive and says that "Shenmue III is the equivalent to Author's Cinema", Spanish site Alfa Beta Juega has 72k followers on Twitter https://www.alfabetajuega.com/analisis/analisis-shenmue-iii

EDIT 2:
A 74 from TuPlayStation.es https://www.tuplaystation.es/shenmue-iii/analisis-de-shenmue-3/ not a very substantial review, nothing new really

 

[Real1]

HUGE, HUGE HUUUUUGE THANKS TO @Kyo_JP for hyperlinking EVERY SINGLE REVIEW!!!!!!!!

^Updating list with the impression and review posted above as well

 

[WuyingRen]

The Express gave the game 4/5.

Also, here are the Famitsu reviews that you’re missing.

I agree with others that the scores should all be combined into one list regardless of platform or whether or not the site is on MC.

Edit:Found the Game Reactor Norway review too.

 

[Real1]

The Express gave the game 4/5.

Also, here are the Famitsu reviews that you’re missing.

I agree with others that the scores should all be combined into one list regardless of platform or whether or not the site is on MC.

Edit:Found the Game Reactor Norway review too.

Updated.

I'll combine them at a later time. Well split it up really, one version with only metacritic, one with all scores.

 

[spud1897]

This may not go on Metacritic but OPM:UK will have their review of Shenmue III in this months edition.

 

[Kyo_JP]

This may not go on Metacritic but OPM:UK will have their review of Shenmue III in this months edition.

Speaking of UK magazines, when is usually Edge released over there? I asume they will release a review this month or next one

 

[spud1897]

Speaking of UK magazines, when is usually Edge released over there? I asume they will release a review this month or next one

This months came out last week. No review. It should be in next months magazine.

 

[spud1897]

7/10 from OPM UK

 

[Real1]

7/10 from OPM UK

View attachment 6399

Adding to list using your post as URL