Well, Jim Sterling is known for being "subversive" and like to shit on things or incense stuffs, just to go against the general opinion. I mean that's what he is now, a parody of himself. A while back, I thought he was a pretty good journalist, because he wasn't afraid to shit on AAA exclusive, and kinda tell what every other journalists didn't dare to.
If I recall correctly, Jim Sterling even made a video stating that Shenmue was never good, and that Shenmue 1&2 were completely overhyped shit. So yeah, I wouldn't listen to him.
And Super Eyepatch Wolf is more an entertainer than a critic. His videos are well made, good rhythm, editing, funny and all. But it's here for entertaining reasons. You can see on many videos (the one about Shenmue 3 is a good example) that he exaggerates alot of things to make it funny, and often put asides objective parts (positive and negative), because while it would be worth mentioning in a REAL critic, it's not fun nor entertaining to talk about.
Sadly, that's what most people wanna watch. Not people who goes in depth to talk about a game, but people who make stuff entertaining.
I was hesitant to make a video review of Shenmue 3 myself, but when I saw everything I wanted to talk about and presents and explain why it is good or not, it would be a 1h30-2h videos, and, not only do I not have time to do this right now, thus I should replay Shenmue 3 before doing so, but I really, don't know anybody who would be interested in a 2h video on Shenmue 3, except diehard fans