- Joined
- Oct 6, 2018
@iknifaugood
i feel like I’ve addressed your points in my previous posts and we’ll just keep going round in circles. You keep saying he had the story all planned out and I made the point that having the story planned out beforehand doesn’t guarantee a good implementation (see novels and film adaptations). I’ve read all your other posts re. the topic too and for the most part don’t agree. There are definitely some things that I would say you’re bang on the money, but it is what it is.
@hmjohnny
see I feel that S3 actually proves the exact opposite. What Suzuki has achieved with all those limitations in place is really quite remarkable and proves, at least to me, that he is capable of grand accomplishments, and even more so with the appropriate resources and team around him. I don’t for a second agree that S1 & S2 were a success despite Yu. He was the glue that held everything together and directed the project. Obviously he’s not capable of doing everything himself so he surrounded himself with the best possible people to see his vision out, with a clear directive coming from him. I really don’t mean this is any way confrontationally but I do think the idea that S1 & S2 were as good as they were “despite” Yu is nonsense.
i feel like I’ve addressed your points in my previous posts and we’ll just keep going round in circles. You keep saying he had the story all planned out and I made the point that having the story planned out beforehand doesn’t guarantee a good implementation (see novels and film adaptations). I’ve read all your other posts re. the topic too and for the most part don’t agree. There are definitely some things that I would say you’re bang on the money, but it is what it is.
@hmjohnny
see I feel that S3 actually proves the exact opposite. What Suzuki has achieved with all those limitations in place is really quite remarkable and proves, at least to me, that he is capable of grand accomplishments, and even more so with the appropriate resources and team around him. I don’t for a second agree that S1 & S2 were a success despite Yu. He was the glue that held everything together and directed the project. Obviously he’s not capable of doing everything himself so he surrounded himself with the best possible people to see his vision out, with a clear directive coming from him. I really don’t mean this is any way confrontationally but I do think the idea that S1 & S2 were as good as they were “despite” Yu is nonsense.