I played ME 2 and 3 and I especially loved the 2nd. Maybe I should try Andromeda somtime in the future.
How good was it, like a 6 or 7? I hope that series makes a come-back in the future.
Alright this is gonna be long, lol.
For me the original trilogy it's an absolutely 10/10. I loved the universe, the story, but most of all, the characters. The progression of the characters of ME2 with the loyalty missions and they living in your ship it's amazing. ME3 has some tough moments with a lot of characters, it's like the ending of that travel for a lot of them.
What happened with Andromeda (memes about motion faces aside, because that's fixed almost at the moment but that was it, it was too late, the meme was too big and across the internet, and in the worst case scenario you have mods ((nobody says a shit about the modding community making Skyrim great, because it's almost unplayable in the vanilla version right?)) to make it better) it's that the original trilogy has set up a too high standard, impossible to achieve.
For me, this made (plus the memes) the game unworthy. Still a lot of fans of the OT says today "Andromeda it's, in the best case, a mediocre game". I mean come on, REALLY? Mediocre? Is that the calification you give to this game? For real? I mean, it isnt like the original trilogy but you can't say it's a mediocre game dude. Be serious. The gameplay it's the best of the saga, the open world it's beautiful and quite big with a lot of fauna (remembered me a lot about the open worlds of Gears 5, but much better, with a lot of more content. THAT was a lazy open world ((still a great game tho)) ). So with those two things, you actually CAN'T say this is a mediocre game.
Then you have story and characters. Story it's alright, it's actually not much different of the OT. The two new species are cool (specially the bad ones, in my opinion) and the characters, I'm gonna make it simple:
Your krogan it's cool as Wrex.
Your asari it's pretty cool, very different than Liara.
Your pilots are interesting but they aren't Joker at all.
Your humans are kinda mhe, like the original trilogy actually
Your turian it's kinda a Tali
So basically, yeah, OT characters are better, but MEA arent so far away, and you gotta be fair, you got 3 games to develop your relationships with the characters. Yes, this is a bigger game, still not fair to compare imo.
Your salarian and your quarian and your drell... DOESNT EXISTS. That's, for me, the biggest point that makes this game worst than OT. I missed a Mordin and a Tali. The fact that the are no quarians in the game it's bullshit (Talimancer forevah here). And not only that, the fact that they DIDNT EVEN MENTION THEM till the last minute of the game. I mean, really? Dude, you mentioned all the lost species during the entire game, they never said "hey dude what happened with the quarians?". NOT EVEN A SINGLE TIME. I know it's a DLC (that wont be created) BUT STILL DUDE COME ON.
That was the biggest disappointment to me. No salarian in my crew, but most of all, no quarians in my crew and in the game. It's a shame. They did good with the aliens species of your crew, if you gimme a character that it's kinda like Mordin, and gimme a quarian (doesnt have to be like Tali, you can make it like Peebee, actually, Peebee should be a quarian, that would make SO MUCH SENSE ((you will get this reference when you start your gameplay, when you catch what I meaning, answer me about this)) ).
So, my note? If I'm in a fanboy mode (like I am right now) i'd say a 8.5. More logical mode, a 8. More hater mode, a 7.5. Overall, I did enjoyed it (I didnt catch the ending tho, but didnt mattered) and well, I'm waiting for a ME4 someday. Finger crossed.